RO removes PFAS. Carbon alone doesn’t.
That’s the short answer. Here’s the data behind it and what to actually do.
What the NSF Testing Shows
NSF/ANSI 58 is the certification standard for reverse osmosis drinking water systems. Systems tested and certified under NSF 58 have demonstrated removal of a defined set of contaminants, including PFAS.
NSF P473 is a product-specific certification that tests for PFOA and PFOS reduction. A filter or system carrying NSF P473 has been verified to remove those two specific compounds.
For activated carbon filters: NSF 42 covers taste and odor (chlorine reduction). NSF 53 covers health-related contaminants including some VOCs and lead. Neither NSF 42 nor NSF 53 requires PFAS testing.
The research on activated carbon for PFAS shows inconsistent results. Granular activated carbon (GAC) used in some under-sink filters reduces PFAS, but the reduction rate varies widely depending on the carbon source, contact time, and which PFAS compounds are present. Longer-chain PFAS (PFOA, PFOS) are better adsorbed than shorter-chain compounds.
Bottom line: If you need reliable PFAS reduction, look for NSF 58 or NSF P473 certification on the specific filter or system you’re buying.
Step-by-Step: Choosing a PFAS Removal System
Step 1: Confirm PFAS Is Present
A mail-in lab test using EPA Method 533 or 537.1 tells you which PFAS compounds are present and at what concentrations. This matters because:
- Different PFAS compounds have different removal rates across filter types
- You may have compounds beyond PFOA and PFOS that aren’t covered by NSF P473
- Knowing the concentration helps you track treatment effectiveness over time
Best Mail-In Water Tests covers certified labs that offer PFAS panels.
Step 2: Choose Your Treatment Type
Under-sink RO system (recommended for most households)
An under-sink RO installs below your kitchen sink and produces filtered water on demand to a dedicated faucet. It treats drinking and cooking water without affecting the rest of your home’s water supply.
Capacity: typically 50–100 gallons per day. More than enough for a household’s drinking and cooking needs.
Key certifications to look for: NSF 58 (required), NSF P473 (additional PFAS confirmation).
Cost: $150–$400 for the unit, plus periodic filter replacement ($50–$100/year).
Whole-house RO system
Treats all water entering the home. Practical if you’re also concerned about PFAS in shower water or have a commercial need. Much more expensive ($3,000–$10,000 installed) and requires professional installation.
Most households don’t need whole-house RO for PFAS. The primary exposure pathway is drinking and cooking water.
Countertop RO
If you rent and can’t install under-sink, countertop RO units connect to your faucet and don’t require drilling. Performance is comparable to under-sink but flow rate may be slower.
Step 3: Verify the Certification
Before buying, look up the specific model number on the NSF product search database (nsf.org) to confirm certification. Manufacturer marketing claims on packaging don’t always match actual certifications. The NSF database shows exactly what was tested and what the system is certified for.
Step 4: Install and Establish a Filter Replacement Schedule
For under-sink RO:
- Sediment pre-filter: every 6–12 months
- Carbon pre-filter: every 6–12 months
- RO membrane: every 2–5 years
- Post-filter (polishing carbon): every 12 months
A TDS (total dissolved solids) meter is a cheap way to monitor membrane performance. Test your filtered water quarterly. If TDS climbs from near zero toward 50+ mg/L, the membrane is losing effectiveness.
Step 5: Test After Installation
Run the system for 2–3 weeks before retesting (to flush the new membrane). Then submit a sample to the same certified lab you used before installation. The before/after comparison confirms actual removal rates in your specific water conditions.
What Won’t Work
Boiling — concentrates PFAS, doesn’t remove them.
Standard pitcher filters — not reliably effective unless NSF P473 certified.
Refrigerator filters — same issue.
Softeners — don’t remove PFAS at all. Different technology entirely.
Basic faucet filters — NSF 42 carbon filters won’t cut it.
Product Recommendations
See the full comparison: Best Under-Sink RO Systems